Perfect Potato Salad for the 4th of July!

Summer holidays and potato salad, always boiled down to the name “Aunt Frances," not only my Aunt Frances, but Bill’s Aunt Frances also.  

They were the “go to ladies” for potato salad back then, but unfortunately I never got either of their recipes and so am always on the hunt for the perfect potato salad recipe, and this one I’ve got for you today is close.

This recipe, slightly adapted here, was in the Chicago Tribune by Leah Eskin, in her “Home on the Range” food column.  

By the way, she has a great cookbook, Slices of Life, that’s not only filled with recipes, but a generous helping of her life stories that happened on her way cooking and baking when she was young, and later for her own family. 

Back to this recipe, it strays a little from traditional potato salad and makes the most of summer, with its surprising good taste.  

I would’ve never thought of including peas in potato salad ~ it’s a perfect match, accented by mayonnaise combined with sour cream, dill, lemon zest and Dijon mustard, with lots of chopped red onion thrown in and garnished on top with sliced olives for Bill, the potato salad conniseur!

It’s not a sweet dish, just savory and delicious, that’s good warm, but is just as delicious when chilled. 

This is my new go-to potluck dish 
for summer here in the 
Midwest ~
we do love a good potluck!

Potato Salad w/Peas
Printable recipe


3 pounds red-skin potatoes
1 cup frozen peas
1 cup chopped red onion
½ cup mayonnaise
½ cup sour cream
½ teaspoon dried dill or ¼ cup snipped dill fronds
2 tablespoons Dijon mustard
½ teaspoon finely grated lemon zest
Kosher salt and freshly ground pepper
Sliced green olives, for garnish, optional


Boil:  Settle potatoes in a large pot.  Cover with cold, salted water by 1 inch.  Bring to a rolling boil, turn down to a low boil and cook until potatoes are easily pierced with a skewer, about 25 minutes.

Cut:  When potatoes are cool enough to handle (but still warm), cut into 1-inch cubes. Pile into a large bowl.  Sprinkle in peas (no need to defrost) and red onion.

Mix:  Whisk together mayo, sour cream, dill, mustard, zest, and salt and pepper to taste.  Pour this dressing over potatoes.  Mix gently with a soft spatula.  Arrange sliced olives over top, if desired. 

Serve:  I like this still warm, but it's good at any temperature; keep cold for picnics. 

8 Servings


and have a safe
Happy 4th!


  1. I am constantly striving for the perfect potato salad! My mother put peas and hard-boiled eggs in her's. Happy 4th of July!!


    1. Hi Bonnie! I thought about the hard-boiled eggs too late, it would've been great with them. Happy 4th!

  2. My favorite potatoe salad has almost all the ingredients mentioned in your recipe. It's indeed delicious. We like it cold.
    Enjoy 4th of July celebration!

    1. Thanks, Duta! We like it cold also most of the time. Take care and have a great weekend!

  3. Sounds delicious Pam !
    Hope you have a nice 4th july !

    1. Thanks, Gloria! We love the 4th! You take care and have a great weekend in your neck of the woods!

  4. This sounds like a great potato salad! Never have thought to add peas in mine! Happy Fourth of July!

    1. Hi Nellie! Me too until now. Happy 4th to you!

  5. Pam, I hope that you and yours have a terrific 4th of July weekend! My wife and all of our friends would love this potato salad but as for myself, I never could understand the attraction of cold potatoes in any format. Take Care, Big Daddy Dave

    1. Thanks, David! I definitely get you with the cold potato salad. Here's wishing you and yours a great July 4th weekend! Take care

  6. I think potato salad is in our Midwest blood, Pam :) Love the addition of peas in this version!

  7. Sounds like a good recipe. I think I like ALL potato salads -- with mayo or vinaigrette or mustard, with onion or no onion, with hard boiled eggs or not, with peas or celery or pickles or parsley or anything. Today I tried Marcella Hazan's recipe for a potato salad with capers, olives, and anchovies: not to every taste, but I thought it was great.

    best... mae at

    1. Thanks, Mae! I usually add pickles, but capers sounds great, not so sure about anchovies though. There are so many variations but I really liked the addition of peas in this, more savory. Take care

  8. I make my potato salad much like this recipe.. but I have never added olives , what was I missing!!!! Olives are my favorite!!!!!! have a great 4th!!!!

    1. Hi Leslie! Good to see you! Ha! Kind of funny with the olives; Bill thinks they're a must on potato salad. Happy 4th!

  9. Sounds like a terrific potluck addition - I bet it's one of the first ones eaten! Happy 4th of July to you and your family.

    1. Thanks, Beth! It's a great summertime dish. Happy 4th your way!

  10. Always good to have new additions to the file.
    Never had potato salad with peas though--interesting.

    I have a recipe up if you want to add another to your file.

    Happy 4th!!

    M : )

    1. Hi Melinda! I'd never had it with peas either, but will from now on, it's good! Happy 4th!

  11. a good looking potato salad recipe. Happy 4th to you and your family.....It's raining here, but we are not going to complain...much needed rain. Enjoy this day and blessings to you all...

    1. Thanks, Shug! Stay dry. :-) It's cool here but going to warm up tomorrow. Happy 4th to you!

  12. This recipe sounds fabulous! I hope you have a great 4th!

  13. Hi Pam,
    Was a busy few days, now I can enjoy your post. Well I must say that your Potato Salad w/Peas recipe looks and sounds scrumptious! I have had olives in a potato salad before but never this is a first. I printed this one out and will be using this soon. Love the combo of ingredients and it is not a hard one to prepare. Thanks for sharing this one, ps I also had an Aunt Frances. I hope that your July 4th was awesome and God Bless the USA! Have a great rest of the week dear friend...
    Hugs Dottie :)


Post a Comment


Sandwiches are wonderful. You don’t need a spoon or a plate.
- Paul Lynde

I am happy to hear what you have to say, and appreciate your taking the time to stop by and leave a comment.
Keep Smiling,


I want to enjoy my life, and food is a big part of it.

~ Gwyneth Paltrow

Popular posts from this blog

Tender and Delicious Italian-Style Baked Chicken Breasts

Succulent Slow-cooker Pork Loin in Gravy

Bubba’s Winning Homemade Summer Sausage

The Best Lemon Pound Cake ~ I’m Telling You the Truth!

Dinner Party

Dinner Party
Jules-Alexandre Grun

Since 2009